10 November 2007
The most promising new treatment for severe depression is not a pill. It is a permanent implant that shocks the brain. Is this what joy looks like?
In the middle of a room in the Cleveland Clinic's Surgical Center, lies a patient on an operating table, the back half of her shaven head hidden behind a plastic curtain. Four pins, one driven into either side of her forehead, the other two in back, hold a titanium halo fast to her skull. An anesthesiologist, several nurses and her psychiatrist cluster around the bed. Behind the curtain, the neurosurgeon surveys her brain, white and snaked with thin red arteries, through a pair of small holes he drilled in the top of her skull. As so few pain receptors are located in the brain, only local anesthetic numbs her head. She is awake during the procedure—or as awake as she can be. For the past 20 years, she has suffered from severe depression, a crippling strain of the disease that afflicts as many as four million people. Years of therapy, at least 10 different drugs and six courses of the whole-brain shock technique known as Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) all failed to bring her lasting relief. Her final hope is this operation, a radical form of neurosurgery called Deep-Brain Stimulation, or DBS. Whereas ECT—a treatment that has been demonized in movies like One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest but is still used on roughly 100,000 patients a year—floods the brain with electricity from the outside, this technique delivers a smaller dose of better-targeted current to an area of the brain believed to be a key regulator of mood. Wires thread beneath the skin from their place in the brain and plug into two battery-run stimulators implanted in the chest. About the size of an iPod nano, each stimulator constantly pumps out current, bathing a small region of brain tissue in electricity. If ECT is the equivalent of slapping defibrillators against a heart-attack victim's chest, deep-brain stimulation is the pacemaker that prevents the attack in the first place. On the operating table, the patient closes her eyes. The neuro surgeon slowly inserts a wire as thin as a fishing line through the left hole in her skull, using the halo as a guide. His team has already mapped out his route using a precise 3-D reconstruction of the patient's brain compiled from 180 MRI scans. His target is a chunk of neurons associated with energy and mood. After the tip of the wire is in the right spot, he repeats the process on the other side. Within 90 minutes of the first cut, the patient has two electrodes lodged in the center of her brain. Now it is time to charge them up. On the other side of the curtain, the patient's psychiatrist, tells her that everything is ready. The psychiatrist has a clear, soothing voice and a comforting, boyish face. He is the kind of person you would want to talk to if someone was about to shock your brain. At his signal, two volts of electricity, enough to power a wristwatch, course through the wires and radiate outward from the tip a few millimeters in every direction. Millions of neurons bask in the electricity, and the effect is fairly immediate. The patient feels warm at first, a bit flushed; and then it happens. The room looks brighter to her. The faces, the big, circular lights overhead, the ceiling—they all seem clearer. The psychiatrist asks her how she feels. "I am really happy," she replies, clearly surprised. "I feel like I could get up and do all sorts of things." Even more telling than her words is the look on her face. For the first time in 20 years, with a halo bolted to her head and two freshly drilled holes in her skull, she smiles.
![](../attachment/attachment/37_image001.jpg)
Zeinab Ahmed